Although I love them all...if I could only have four then these would be my top picks. I've bundled them together and discounted them 10% in case you feel the same.
Stagecoach Italian Napa Valley Extra Virgin Olive Oil - love the pungency and knowing its from local dirt.
Lemon Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Our first flavored olive oil and the only reason Emily would eat her greens when she was young.
Cask 85 Red Wine Vinegar - Near and dear to my heart...100% Napa Valley and aged beyond anything else...tied to this land...a mellow herbaceous tart wine vinegar.
Balsamic Tradizionale - This needs no explanation!